Dirty Dollar Bills
Fernando
Pena
Professor
Matyakubova
ENG
201
5.21.2015
Dirty
Dollar Bills
The American financial system is a
complex structure that was meant to allow fair opportunity for everyone to
achieve profit and stability. However, despite living in one of the planet’s
wealthiest countries, America hold high rates of income inequality and unequal
distribution. Though there are many factors that contribute to this fact, there
is one that stands out in America due to its popularity. Corruption.
White-Collar Crime does not always mean to inflict physical harm, but the financial
damage caused by these actions are immense and long-lasting.
Due to the lack of knowledge and
regulation, white-collar crime has found itself increased in the United States.
Ranging from awareness to an increased law enforcement presence, there are many
solutions to this issue. Billions of dollars that could be invested into
programs, aid for the less fortunate, and other positives causes find
themselves flushed away due to this complex form of robbery. How has fraud and white-collar crime advance
itself throughout history against the American justice system?
In recent years it has become evident
that the institutions, banks, and politicians that citizens have relied on for
a source of order and stability succumbed to greed. Although it is logical for everyone
to attempt to achieve profit within a capitalist society, one’s greed or yearn
for money should not come with the damage of society as a side effect. Sociologist
Edwin Sutherland describes white collar crime as a crime committed by a person
of respectability and high social status in the course of his occupation. This
can be classified as offenses that are designed to produce financial gain using
some form of deception. This can be done through scams, mail fraud, wire-fraud,
kick-backs, bribery, etc. Technology has advanced the art of this lucrative
crime as well, consider it more as a robbery that has the tendency to go
undetected. Over the course of the pass couple of decades we have seen billions
of dollars stolen from investors and everyday citizen. Another question that
could be asked is why do people do it and where did it start?
White collar crime within the United States
has a rich history even though there isn’t a definite date to when fraud-related
crime began. However, time within our
history that we saw extreme financial was during the Great Depression. This
extreme desperation laid out a very useful playing field for fraudulent
business practices. The stock market crash of 1929 lead to the closings of
multiple banks and unemployment skyrocketing. On top of the dust bowl that
effected the Midwest, our economy was in a state of turmoil and people did not
know where to turn for their money.
Also a lack of financial education was
also an issue for investors or casual civilians that wasn’t necessarily aware
about the banking system. Sadly on top of a lack of rights in comparison to
men, women appeared to have the most targeted. According to George Robb (2006),
when it came to women during 1850-1920s he states that “Not only were these
women lacking in business experience and acumen, but they were ill-placed to
fight him in court should it come to that… Although women had an
important role in financing the industrial economy, they had very little
control over their assets. In the United States, New York became the first state
to give married women rights to their own property in 1848.” Some business-owners even wondered if the
large number of female shareholders in certain companies might even encourage
fraud.” Financial literacy was a skill that was seemed as a male-trait, hence
why many females fell victim to these tricks.
An example of fraud that Robb explains
can include a broker and an investor, in this situation a female by the name of
Ann Slack invests 3,500 dollars in government securities and then the trustee
(in the person who is “trusted” with the money) dies randomly. A clerk who
works under the broker decides to transfer over the funds and uses a fake death
certificate to spread out the original security investment. What ends of
happening to Ann Slack is that she ended up losing around 3,500 dollars and yet
no one suspected a thing. (Robb, 2006)
The criminals and major instances
of fraud that have risen in recent history have been a lot more devastating due
to their wider-scale damage. One might ask why has it been so commonplace for
businesses to go ahead and steal millions from everyday citizens. The answer
can be seen within the idea of criminal opportunity. According to Carter Hay
and Walter Forrest (2008), “Self-control theory is grounded in the classic view
that human behavior largely involves the self-interested pursuit of pleasure.
Crime is recognized as a universally desirable way of pursuing self-interest
because it provides “immediate, easy, and short-term pleasure” (Gottfredson and
Hirschi, 1990: 41)”. When someone is successful at any activity or pursuit,
even when it is involved with criminal intentions, they would want to carry it
out again. Why stop at stealing one million dollars, or even two million
dollars? Criminal opportunity can be seen as a “booster” to activities such as
fraud. Also within the United States, we operate under a system known as
“laissez-faire.” The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines “Laissez-faire” as a
policy that allows businesses to operate with very little interference from the
government. Although the government can regulate big business, it is not
typical for gov’t to play a major role in business actions or decisions; the
capitalist system leads to a free-for-all and this stage sets the tone for
cheaters.
It can be seen as astonishing to some of the amount of money that can be lost just due to one individual. One of the criminals that gained nationwide attention for their crimes includes
Bernard
Madoff. Ott (2010) describes Madoff as Chairman of a prominent Wall Street investment firm and a former Chairman of
the NASDAQ Stock Exchange. Ott also explain that over a period spanning at
least 15 years, Madoff operated a Ponzi scheme responsible for bilking
investors of billions of dollars. A Ponzi scheme is described by hbr.org as “a
structure named after Charles Ponzi, who created the first such scheme in the
1920’s by selling investments that were said to generate healthy returns but
were actually paid out from the funds brought in by new investors.” This leads
to an unsustainable amount cycle of acquisitions and redemptions. Billions were
lost and Madoff was sentenced to 150 years for his crimes.
Other famous examples of a white-collar
criminal includes Simeon Mogilevich, who is currently the 10th most
wanted man on the FBI’s wanted list. Mogilevich defrauded thousands of
investors in a Canada company and caused investors to lose around 150 million
dollars. Finally, a 3rd example of someone accused of fraudulent
activity is Jordan Belfort, who went to jail for swindling around 200 million
dollars from investors. Jordan, who also happens to be a Bronx native, was the
inspiration behind the film “The Wolf of Wall Street”, a film staring Leonardo
DiCaprio that highlighted his experiences and times at Stratton Oakmont
(brokerage house)
A common misconception is that
white-collar crime and fraud is only involved with the high class and wealthy,
when it reality some of the people that get hit hardest by white-collar crime
are the poor. Money that could be invested in re-building schools or providing
community programs is thrown away within these schemes. Also similarly to how a
good percentage of women lacked financial literacy during the early 1900s,
financial illiteracy is also prevalent amongst the poor. According to Carswell
and Bachtel (2009), out of 2132 census tracts from their research regarding Mortgage
Fraud and the effects it has on communities, they stated that “For socioeconomic
characteristics measured by percentage, the overall national data showed that
the more concentrated the problem of fraud became within a Census tract, the
more likely indicators such as unemployment rate, poverty rate, and vacancy
rate tended to increase as well.”
Although no one should
have to succumb to these terrible acts, people in areas of low-income who
already rely on government assistance fall on the top of the list of people who
are most vulnerable and most damaged from fraud.
It is evident that fraud has
inflicted a damaging toll in our financial and political economy, but one can
wonder how law enforcement responds to this type of crime. Usually when it
comes to a robbery involving merchandise or money, uniformed officers are on
arrive and apprehend the suspects involved. Fraud usually consist of long-term schemes
and plots to gain illegalized profit. Therefore, law enforcement responses to
fraud involve long-term lucrative investigations with the help of forensic
accountants, fraud-examiners, attorneys, and special agents and uniformed
police officers. The schemes can pass borders and law enforcement across the
globe may have to communicate with one another and work together to bring
criminals to justice. In August 2009, Italian police and prosecutors thwarted a
multi-billion dollar securities scheme orchestrated by the Sicilian Mafia which
targeted already burdened financial firms in the USA and elsewhere. The police
arrested as many as 20 people across the globe, including Italy, Spain,
Venezuela and Brazil. (Ott, 2010) In terms of our shores, the two main law
enforcement agencies within the U.S that focuses on responding to fraud include
the secret service and the FBI, hence why many federal agents are former
accountants. These agencies will frequently find themselves co-operating with
foreign law enforcement to crack down on these cases. Agents will find
themselves going undercover to bring down the bad guys. In the Wall Street
Journal’s Youtube channel, “FBI Sting Tries to Rein in Penny Stock Fraud”, an
undercover agent poses as a manager by the name of “John Kelly” and convinces
another manager to incriminate himself to the scheme.
Despite the toll that fraud has
placed on our society there are actions that one can take that can help prevent
themselves from becoming a victim. In terms of preventing fraudulent
transactions involving your money, District Attorney Investigator Yohanna Pena
said “There are many shades people/businesses that would do anything just to
gain a profit and if it means throwing your livelihoods in the trash then so be
it. Be on top of your credit cards, information and make sure you have trust in
whoever has access to your money before you make a final
decision/purchase." Simply adding a heightened sense of caution can help
prevent someone from becoming a victim significantly. Others type of prevention
strategies includes safeguarding one’s purse in public, destroying receipts or
expired financial documents, and even keeping contact with a bank when anything
suspicious pops up in one’s purchase history.
-
In conclusion, fraud and corruption are
damaging in the sense that they cause widespread damage within our country
throughout our history. Although the crime and the criminals within themselves
have advanced their craft, the law is always one step ahead. Billions of
dollars and livelihoods have been destroyed as well; it is our duty to ensure
that we take care of our finances while respecting the money of others. Although
government shouldn’t greatly interfere with business and we all should try our
best to achieve profit, it is crucial that we do not neglect society as well.
Bibliography
Carswell,
A., & Bachtel, D. (2009). Mortgage fraud: A risk factor analysis of
affected communities. Crime, Law & Social Change, 52(4), 347-364.
Nguyen,
T. H., & Pontell, H. N. (2010). Mortgage origination fraud and the global
economic crisis. Criminology & Public Policy, 9(3), 591-612.
Ott,
T. P. (2010). US law enforcement strategies to combat organized crime threats
to financial institutions. Journal Of Financial Crime, 17(4), 375-386.
van Onna, J. R., van der
Geest, V. R., Huisman, W., & Denkers, A. M. (2014). Criminal Trajectories
of White-collar Offenders. Journal Of Research In Crime & Delinquency,
51(6)
WHOFER,
M., LICHLITER, M., & MAKIA, B. (2014). FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS FRAUD. American Criminal Law Review, 51(4),
1209-1264.
YouTube,
'FBI Sting Tries To Rein In Penny Stock Fraud'. N.p., 2015. Web. 21 May 2015.