Thursday, May 7, 2015

Journal 3

Fernando Pena
2/18/2015
Professor Matyakubova
English 201
Literacy Reflection of “Proficiency” by Shannon Nichols
              The narrative of “Proficiency” by Shannon Nichols describes the experience in which the author, Shannon, took a proficiency exam during the 8th grade and the damage it did to her appreciation of writing. Prior to the examination, Shannon was an A student who did well in all subjects. She never held a G.P.A that was under 3.0 and she was even on the Honor Roll, these characteristics might have supported the idea that Shannon was passionate on studying. She gave the exam a lot of study time and grew anxious and unfortunately she failed the writing section of the exam even after she passed all the other sections of the test. The failing of this exam lead to sadness and ultimately, a loss of appreciation towards writing as a whole.
          Although I may not agree with how she responded towards the grade, I understand how devastating a bad grade can be on something you worked really hard on. For one to be motivated on a topic or idea, progress has to be shown and when you fail the same test twice, the result could be negative. To connect this reading to my personal life, I was known to be good at Mathematics during my time in elementary and middle school. However, once I failed Trigonometry twice in high school, from that point on I lost a good amount of appreciation towards math as a subject. That lack of interest still follows me today.

        In life, many people will judge and critique your work, however it is up to you on how you will use that information to benefit yourself. Rubrics can only go so far to determine someone’s skill as a writer, especially since there are so many different uses and types of writing samples. I think that it’s safe to say that Shannon’s story is similar to many students across the planet that have lost their passion due to grading. It is up to us however, to use critiques to our advantage and not to our downfall. 

No comments:

Post a Comment