Thursday, May 7, 2015

Journal 7

Fernando Pena
Eng 201
4.20.15
Journal 7

             In Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “The Birthmark”, the reoccurring theme of pursuing perfection was spread out throughout the story. The Birthmark describes the story of Alymer, a scientist who attempts to remove a birthmark from his wife; Georgiana. Alymer becomes obsessed over the birthmark on Georgiana’s face and creates a potion that he is confident will somehow remove the hand-shaped marking; believing that the mark was the only thing in the way of Georgiana’s perfection. Georgiana is originally shocked and is quite hesitant over Alymer’s goal to remove her birthmark. Eventually, Georgiana accepts the potion and unfortunately ends up dying in the midst of the experiment to the amusement of Alymer and his assistant.

           The pursuit of perfection is what ended up being Georgiana’s downfall but it also exposes the true intentions of others. It should be noted that Alymer did not wish to remove the mole until he and Georgiana were married. Rather than accepting her imperfections he wished to mold her to a perfect human, which is impossible. It could be said that apart from Alymer wishing to pursue perfection, he felt that Georgiana was more of a possession rather than a partner, which displays the narcissism of Alymer. All in all, the story gives excellent reasoning on why the pursuit of perfection never succeeds. 

No comments:

Post a Comment