Fernando
Pena
Literary
Analysis
John
Jay College
Professor
Matyakubova
3.24.2015
Race has always brought conflict
amongst people in the planet. Whether it is for personal reasons or for
nationalistic tendencies, race not only makes us unique, but at times pushes us
apart as people. In “A letter from Birmingham Jail” by Dr. King, Martin
displays to us through his writing how bad this divide has become. Dr. King was
originally incarcerated for participating in non-violent protests against
segregation, these protests were part of the “Birmingham Campaign” that
included sit-ins and marches against segregation within Birmingham, Alabama. The
letter he wrote from his cell were directed towards white clergymen that spoke
against his cause and his letter became a pivotal piece of literature for the
civil rights movement. “Letter from Birmingham Jail” displayed the conflicts
that racial injustice brought about in terms of society and the law.
Martin Luther King was born on
January 15th 1929 in Atlanta, Georgia and from an early age was
exposed to racism and discrimination while being raised in the south. His
father Martin Luther King Sr. was also a civil rights activist who ended up
outliving his son due to King’s assassination in 1968. Both of these people
experienced a method of legalized racism known as the Jim Crow Laws. The Jim
Crow laws were enacted after the Reconstruction period of the south that
continued until 1965, these laws lowered the quality of life for African
Americans and made things unequal. On top of these laws, America was now
leaving World War II and entering a Pre-Vietnam time of change and progression.
An attempt of change by civil rights leaders was the Birmingham campaign. The
campaign consisted of various marches and sit-ins that was carried out by
various civil rights leaders and organizations. Despite threats and
imprisonment, King stood firm by sending out a response to Alabama Clergymen
describing the reasoning of the protests.
The actual “Letter from Birmingham
Jail” was originally written from by King himself and was a through response to
clergymen who considered the Birmingham protests “unwise and untimely.” King
isn’t new to criticisms from outside sources, he states that “If I sought to
answer all of the criticism that cross my desk, my secretaries would be engaged
in little else in the course of the day.” These criticisms were also directed
towards the Southern Christian Leadership Conference that was also marching
with him in Birmingham. King continues the introduction to his letter by
stating that the local SCLC branch invited him to Birmingham to protest in the
first place. This isn’t meant to justify his reason for being there since it is
clear that the clergymen weren’t seeing the bigger picture on why it was
essential for this protest to occur. Dr. King had the right as a human being to
be there and to protest the unjust law. "The answer is found in the fact
that there are two types of laws: there are just laws, and there are unjust
laws. One would agree with St. Augustine that "An unjust law is no law at
all." is a quote said by King that stands out in its significance due its
message. It is our duty as humans to fight unjust laws, and the Birmingham
march set out to do just that.
To further support the idea that the
overall legal system of the United States tended to ignore the human rights of
minorities during the civil rights movement, one can look at the law
enforcement response within the Birmingham campaign. Unlike race-related
protests that were violent and unlawful such as the L.A Riots and the Ferguson
Protests, the Birmingham campaign was carried out with poise and peace. Despite
this peaceful response by the people, they were combated by police officers and
fire-fighters with very violent responses. This photo from “Rhetoric and
Publics Affairs” (cited by Johnson Davi) from the 1963 Birmingham Campaign
gives an accurate display of the conflict and brutality experienced by these
protestors.
Ironically,
the
constitution at this point still gave people the right to peacefully assemble.
Police officers are also mentioned in King’s letter when he states “You warmly
commended the Birmingham police force for keeping "order" and
"preventing violence." I doubt that you would have so warmly
commended the police force if you had seen its dogs sinking their teeth into
unarmed, nonviolent Negroes.” King’s masterfully expresses his frustration by
offering a change of perspective to the clergymen and concludes his piece by
saying that he could not join in on the praise of the Birmingham Police
Department.
the
constitution at this point still gave people the right to peacefully assemble.
Police officers are also mentioned in King’s letter when he states “You warmly
commended the Birmingham police force for keeping "order" and
"preventing violence." I doubt that you would have so warmly
commended the police force if you had seen its dogs sinking their teeth into
unarmed, nonviolent Negroes.” King’s masterfully expresses his frustration by
offering a change of perspective to the clergymen and concludes his piece by
saying that he could not join in on the praise of the Birmingham Police
Department.
Another aspect of King’s letter is
the mentioning of religion; conflicts within the church strengthened between
Baptist African Americans and Catholic/Christian Caucasians. King uses the
teachings of the bible and its messages to counter the clergymen since the
clergymen themselves happen to be men in strong faith with God, King himself is
a minister and uses the story of Apostle Paul leaving his village of Tarsus and
carrying the gospel of Jesus Christ to the Greco Roman world as a display of
knowledge of Christianity. Despite King being told that the teaching of Jesus
and overall progression comes by slowly in Christianity, he is convinced that
serious consequences would arise towards the church if a common ground couldn’t
be established. The feeling of pulled between two sides is one that comes up
with King. He describes between caught in a battle between African Americans
that have more or less conformed to their situation as low-class humans (which
includes wealthy African-Americans that are somewhat indifferent to the situation)
and those who feel that a violent response is a necessary action. This ties
back to religion since King also reports of people moving away from
Christianity when he states: “It is expressed in the various black nationalist
groups that are springing up across the nation, the largest and best known
being Elijah Muhammad's Muslim movement. Nourished by the Negro's frustration
over the continued existence of racial discrimination, this movement is made up
of people who have lost faith in America, who have absolutely repudiated
Christianity.” One could have only imagined the thoughts the clergymen had on
this. A question that had to have been was on the faith the individual against
his inner hatred towards others.
King’s letter touches up on the idea
of nationalism and how it is inevitable that they (marchers and the SCLC) will
end up reaching their goals not only because of their determination, but
because they are Americans. King appears to show the most confidence toward the
closing of his letter, he discusses American freedom and how it ties to their
mission when he states “We will reach the goal of freedom in Birmingham and all
over the nation, because the goal of America is freedom. Abused and scorned
though we may be, our destiny is tied up with America's destiny.” See
regardless of skin color King asserts that he and his fellow marchers are still
American citizens regardless how one tries to look at the situation, and King
continues to remain unfazed despite his incarceration and mistreatment.
King’s letter was a powerful piece of
literature that sprung up from the civil rights movement that displayed how
knowledge can always triumph over a negative ideologies, he did an excellent
job of discussing how racial injustice would be quite damaging towards American
society, but did King’s work in total eliminate racism in America? Well, yes
and no. African Americans still find themselves falling behind in our country
in comparison to Caucasians on multiple standards, some say that these difficulties
may have to do with race. In “One Hundred
Years of Race and Crime” by Paul Butler, he further emphasizes the African
American struggle decades after King’s death when he states “If we look at
black-white racial disparities in education, housing, health care, and
employment, the ratio is usually 2:1 or 3:1. So, for example, the black unemployment
rate is often twice the white unemployment rate.” Butler also discusses the
“New Jim Crow” that lurks in America, although there aren’t any laws that blatantly
discriminate or attempt to segregate African-Americans or any minority for that
matter, Butler
says that there are more blacks in the criminal justice system now
(incarcerated, on probation or parole, awaiting trial) than were slaves in
1850. In 2006, one in nine young black men were in prison, and black men were
eight times more likely to be in jail or prison than white men. (Pg. 1047).There
has been a consistent disadvantage in the African American community, but there
are positives to the situation. Butler also discusses on how he himself is a
professor and how even the president of the United States is an
African-American. The idea of a black man running the country during the letter
to Birmingham Jail was unheard of, one can only think what the future will
hold.
In conclusion, racial injustice
damaged the fabric of our American Society during the 60s and throughout our
time as a nation. It appears that will other countries advanced hand-and-hand
with one another in terms of race, we’ve still fallen behind. Improvements are
being made daily within our country and it seems that every day is better than
the last for equality. It is still however crucial that we tie ourselves to our
roots (regardless of skin color) and remember what people gave up for us to
hand these liberties. “Letter from Birmingham Jail” is an example of human
achievement and is a great display on how racial injustice is always weaker
than the power of equality.
References:
BUTLER,
P. (2010). ONE HUNDRED YEARS OF RACE AND CRIME. Journal Of Criminal Law & Criminology, 100(3), 1043-1060.
Johnson,
D. (2007). MARTIN LUTHER KING JR.'S 1963 BIRMINGHAM CAMPAIGN AS IMAGE EVENT. Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 10(1),
1-25.
"Letter
from a Birmingham Jail [King, Jr.]"
No comments:
Post a Comment